|
We dedicate this site to those who have been defrauded by cancer quacks everywhere. If you stumbled across our version of CCRG, then you've come to the right place. We don't have the world's largest database of cancer information, but we do have just about the best collection of cancer misinformation, cancer quacks and criminals that prey on innocent patients and their families. |
Suckers: How Alternative Medicine Makes Fools of Us All
by Rose Shapiro
Suckers reveals how alternative medicine can jeopardize the health of those it claims to treat, leaches resources from treatments of proven efficacy and is largely unaccountable and unregulated. In short, it is an industry that preys on human vulnerability and makes fools of us all. |
If you would like to support our efforts to combat quackery, health and diet fraud we make it easy for you to donate to the cause.
|
Bill O'Neill and the CCRG
|
Bill O'Neill has left the buildingOn or about January 28, 2011, Bill O'Neill's CCRG web site was no longer available on the Internet, even in the archives that used to go back over a dozen years. You can still look at some of the old site if there is a "cache" available on Google Search. A link to the robtex.com web site shows a very confusing pattern for O'Neill's web site. A look inside the door of 99 Fifth Avenue failed to locate Mr. O'Neill, the CCRG, or ISM (Immune System Management). ISM (Aminomics) has announced that they moved to a new home located at 80 Aberdeen, an upscale building in the core of downtown Ottawa. We don't know if Mr. O'Neill has moved his CCRG into that building, or even if this company is still operating. We do know that ISM has had a few of their natural health products approved by the NHPD, and that some of the OncomatRx products are considered to be Exempted until reviewed. Health Canada has not explained why any of these products were Exempted. You can see a list of OncomatRx exempted products. Canadian Access of Information Requests System (CAIRS) regarding OncomatRx have been pending since the summer of 2006. You can visit a web site maintained by D. McKie at Carleton University and search for oncomatRX if you want to see the original CAIR request. Anyone can file a CAIRS with Health Canada to see how, and why products or devices were approved. Eoghan O'Shea disciplined by the CPSOIn late January 2009, the Disciplinary Committee of the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario (CPSO) said that they would be calling witnesses in a disciplinary hearing against Dr. Eoghan O'Shea. It took over one year for the case to finally be heard.I was at O'Shea's hearing on January 26, 2010 and observed the proceedings and was shocked by the final decision. Nobody was called as a witness and nobody heard Dr. O'Shea's voice in the nearly empty chamber. A number of complaints were made to the CPSO alleging that Dr. O'Shea should be investigated for professional misconduct for his care of patients and for his involvement with Bill O'Neill and the CCRG and related companies. It took many years before it finally ended up with the Discipline Committee of the College. The original charge alleged that Dr. O'Shea, while employed at, consulting for, or affiliated with the Canadian Cancer Research Group failed to maintain the standard of practice of the profession. The hearing began forty-five minutes late and rumours were circulating that the decision had already been made, and that before it was to be announced there was quite an unusual twist. Tim Danson, the famous Toronto criminal counsel, was allowed to address the five-member committee even though he was not retained as a lawyer in the matter before the Committee. Mr. Danson was hired by Bill O'Neill. In a nutshell, this is what Danson stated before the Committee: 2. If any negative statements are made against my client that are unfair there could be consequences 3. Bill O'Neill has a right to be heard to defend himself
The CPSO's counsel told Danson bluntly that there is "no right" to be heard in this hearing. Mr. Danson is not in any position to be an Intervenor in this affair. That didn't stop Danson from schmoozing with the press that came to the hearing during the breaks and after the short deliberations. More later. In my opinion, what happened next was a severe blow to the families who were actually treated by Dr. O'Shea when he worked for Bill O'Neill. Pat McDougall and his daughter Christine sat next to me at the hearing. Kathy McDougall, Pat's other daughter, died of terminal cancer at the time that O'Shea worked for O'Neill. Most of the time we sat in a nearly empty chamber waiting for the shoe to drop on O'Shea. The Committee disappeared frequently into a conference room to supposedly deliberate on a decision and finally a penalty.
Highlights of the Committee's presentationEoghan O'Shea was first registered in Ontario in 1990. He was a specialist in family medicine.He worked for Bill O'Neill from 2000-2006, and during some of that time he was the medical director, or was employed by his organizations. He practiced what the Committee labeled as "complementary medicine". He saw patients at the CCRG who the CPSO said were "terminally ill". He evaluated their "amino acid levels" and compounded supplements and other nutritional products to replace their "amino acid deficiencies" that they claimed would assist their immune system to fight the cancer. The CPSO announced that the lawyers on both sides and the Committee had reached a decision that O'Shea had: 2. Failed to communicate with their own physicians about the treatments and conditions 3. Failed to get informed consent from the patients.
Decision:2. He has one year to attend a medical ethics course run by the CPSO 3. He is prohibited from practicing complementary medicine for terminally ill patients 4. He is prohibited from compounding nutritional supplements for terminally ill patients 5. He is to have nothing to do with Bill O'Neill and the CCRG or any of their companies
What the CPSO failed to do:2. There were no terms of supervision of his existing practice of family medicine
What O'Shea didn't do:2. He was silent during the entire proceedings
My CommentsThere were three reporters who interviewed the McDougalls and Tim Danson after the hearing. Danson stood around in the hallway and spoke about the CCRG and his role in acting as the lawyer for Bill O'Neill. He said that the CCRG's lawsuit against CTV's W-Five special called "Dr. Hope" is still in the works. This stemmed from the undercover investigative report that aired on their network a few years ago.Apparently Bill O'Neill has, according to Mr. Danson, many friends who are in high places in Ottawa that would support Dr. O'Shea and his practice and continue to support Bill O'Neill's efforts. He honestly believed that O'Neill's amino acid therapy did help treat cancer and enhance the immune system. Danson put on a good show for the reporters but it was like pouring acid in an open wound for his clients' victims. Pat McDougall distributed a press kit that include a copy of the Ottawa Sun article written by Donna Casey that appeared on January 22, 2010. Pat's picture appeared on the FRONT page of that issue. He and his daughter Christine also had a long talk with members of the CPSO after the hearing was over. In my opinion, the case is NOT over. The victims of the CCRG have a right to be heard publicly before a tribunal. Complaints about the CCRG have fallen on deaf ears over the last 13 years. Nobody at the Ottawa Police, the RCMP, ministers of health, and members of Parliament have been interested in helping those who have received unapproved care for the terminally ill. Neither has the Competition Bureau and other agencies that are mandated to protect the public (and that includes the CPSO). What can people like the McDougalls do? The complaints process of the CPSO is subject to appeal. HPARB (Health Professions Appeal and Review Board) is an independent agency in Toronto that has the power to review the CPSO Disciplinary Committee's decision. What we don't know are the details of what went on before the hearing that lead to the decision to allow O'Shea to admit that he had violated the standards, or policies of the CPSO. What charts were reviewed? What was not reviewed? Were interviews recorded with the families of those who have died after attending the CCRG? Why were the families who have been victimized by Dr. O'Shea and the CCRG not allowed to present their impact statements before the deliberations were terminated prematurely? Why weren't statements made those people who have had dealings with O'Shea while he worked for Bill O'Neill over the years made public? The CPSO introduced the infamous Complementary Medicine policy that was handed down in 1997 and updated in 2004 to the decision rendered. In my opinion, this policy legitimizes almost all aspects of alternative medicine when performed by medical doctors in Ontario. In other words, doctors who practice alternative medicine need not prove to the prospective patient that any of their nonsense works.
Why is Eoghan O'Shea's name still listed on Bill O'Neill's web site under the title as medical director? Does Bill O'Neill's attorney of record intend to keep this on their ISM web site? Anyone who has had questionable dealings with Bill O'Neill at the CCRG at his clinic in Ottawa, or through his ISM company needs to contact their Member of Parliament, the Competition Bureau, and even law enforcement if they have concerns. O'Neill is probably sitting up there in his mansion in Ottawa smiling right now. After all is said and done, the quacks may have had the last laugh. Those families who have had loved ones perish after having taken them to the CCRG need to start the ball rolling and appeal this ridiculous decision by the CPSO. I am ashamed to have the regulators of my profession act in this manner. The battle continues to have the CPSO act responsively to protect the public. In Ontario, if any regulated health profession fails to act in the best interest of the public, they can be investigated by the government. What interest was served today? In my opinion, Bill O'Neill has won this battle, and we have little hope for any changes that would change things.
Terry Polevoy, MD
News articlesCCRG's Medical director now working elsewhereWe believe that Dr. Eoghan O'Shea, the doctor who had worked at the CCRG in Ottawa and was the medical director of ISM (Immune Systems Management) is now working in a number of other settings. It's probably good news for all concerned. As far as we know, there have been no public statements made by O'Neill, or any of his anonymous alter-egos anywhere on the Internet that O'Shea has moved on in his professional career.
Bill O'Neill's and medical director Eoghan O'Shea's complaints nixed by CPSODr. Eoghan O'Shea the medical doctor who works at the CCRG in Ottawa and was appointed as the medical director of ISM (Immune Systems Management) filed a complaint with the CPSO (College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario) earlier this year.William P. O'Neill, O'Shea's boss at the CCRG and ISM, also filed a complaint about Dr. Polevoy. Fortunately, O'Neill's spin on the facts did not elicit a very sympathetic response from the CPSO. Featured in their response were quotes from what I believe to be O'Neill's dirty little posts, or fake web sites that used my name. In other words I suspect that he pretended to be me. Those posts actually threatened his life. Any fool could tell that the posts or web sites were not mine. In fact, the CPSO dared O'Neill to call the police if I had actually made death threats against him. The truth about O'Neill's nastiness can be heard in his telephone threats below. |
Bill O'Neill failed to shutdown this web siteWithout warning in the late afternoon of May 29, 2009 BlueHost.com my ISP in Provo, Utah responded to Bill O'Neill's DMCA complaint by shutting this web site down. Bill, a man considered to be quite deranged by numerous individuals, must have been gloating in his Ottawa office.For over nine years, Bill has attempted to silence many of his critics, especially Dr. Terry Polevoy, a Waterloo, Ontario medical doctor and founder of HealthWatcher.net. He used what is referred to as the DMCA (Digital Millennium Copyright Act), a U.S. law passed to protect intellectual property values on the Internet. Nobody at Bluehost.com was able to help us get back on the Internet until after my "counter-DMCA" response was sent back to them AND that form was evaluated by their legal department. O'Neill timed his complaint just right. Because it was Friday afternoon, Bluehost's staff claimed that they were unable to do anything until they received a counter-DMCA response from me, AND it must be approved by their legal staff. So, it took until about noon on Monday, June 1st when I finally heard back from from Shari Dixon in their legal department. In order to understand how difficult it was to find anything about their internal policy that resulted in this complete shutdown of all of my web sites I turned to their web site and discovered that the only place that the DMCA was mentioned was on their forums: Bluehost.com's DMCA policy is nowhere to be found on their publicly displayed web pages. It isn't even mentioned in their Terms of Service.Some of my friends sent e-mailed the company's legal department to complain. The main problem was that O'Neill's complaint forced Bluehost.com to shut me down without any evidence that any wrongdoing took place. All that they needed was a simple DMCA complaint. Is that fair? I don't think so. As a consequence of this complaint, each an every page of my web sites were blocked. When my patients tried to reach me on my acnedocs.com web site they were told that it was suspended. It didn't say that there were technical difficulties, they said that it was suspended. This statement inferred that I it was shutdown without any explanation. Had I violated their terms of service, had I libeled someone, was I doing something illegal. Who knew? Bill O'Neill has for nearly a decade claimed to have sued many people. He's left vile messages on my answering machine (see below). And yet, he continues to defraud people who come to him for the treatments of their cancers and other problems. If you have information in regards to Bill O'Neill's similar activites please contact me and I would love to make them public.
Thanks,
Terry Polevoy, MD |
News Releases Ottawa Police Service FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Friday, May 11, 2007, 10:40 am Ottawa Police Service assisted Investigators of the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario (Ottawa) On Thursday May 10th at 10:00 am the Ottawa Police Service assisted in the execution of a warrant by Investigators with the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario under the Regulated Health Professions Act. The warrant was executed at a business located on Fifth Ave. No arrest were made and no charges were laid. The investigation is ongoing by the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario under the Regulated Health Professions Act. -30- Contact: Detective Mitch Proteau Ottawa Police Service Central East District Investigations 613-236-1222 ext 5636
Bill O'Neill's reaction to CTV's W-FIVEWe have some serious questions for Mr. O'Neill and his medical staff.
In case you need reminding about some of Bill O'Neill's activities just check out the following sites.
Bill sues to get a piece of an 88 year old man's will:In 2003, Bill O'Neill's lawyer, Douglas W. Smith, file a lawsuit against the estate of Peter Frederick Bramwell who died at age 88. It seems that there had been a change in his will in 2002 and he named an entity that he called Canadian Cancer Foundation to receive part of his estate. The Canadian Cancer Society contested the attempt by the CCRG to claim the money. The suit was settled and the CCRG had to pay a large fine to the court. Can you imagine trying to take something that was intended as a donation for the Canadian Cancer Society? Shame on Bill and shame on his lawyer, too.Phone threats made to Dr. Terry Polevoy
|